No. C-143-Cf(A)/2008/Selection & Appointment: 17.01.2008
Subject: Recruitment by promotion of the judicial officers to the Uttar Pradesh Higher Judicial Service under Rule 5(a) read with Rule 20 of the Uttar Pradesh Higher Judicial Service Rules, 1975
Rule 5 of the Uttar Pradesh Higher Judicial Service Rules, 1975 dealing with source of recruitment and Rule 20 dealing with recruitment by promotion of the members of Nyayik Sewa are, for convenience, extracted below:
5. Source of recruitment.—The recruitment to the Service shall be made-
(a) by promotion from amongst the Civil Judges (Senior Division) on the basis of Principle of merit-cum-seniority and passing a suitability test.
(b) by promotion strictly on the basis of merit through limited competitive examination of Civil Judges (Senior Division) having not less than five years qualifying service;
(c) by direct recruitment from amongst the Advocates of not less than seven years standing on the first day of January next following the year in which the notice inviting applications is published.
20. Promotion of members of Nyayik Sewa as referred to in Rule 5(a).—
(1) Recruitment by promotion of the members of the Nyayik Sewa shall be made by selection on the principle of merit-cum-seniority and on passing such a suitability test, as prescribed in Appendix G(i).
The field of eligibility for recruitment by promotion shall be confined to four times the number of vacancies to be filled by promotion. The Selection Committee shall prepare a list in order of seniority of the officers eligible under Rule 5(a) of these rules.
The Selection Committee shall, after examining the record of the officers including in the list prepared under sub-rule (2) of this rule make a preliminary selection of the officers who in its opinion are fit to be appointed on the basis of seniority-cum-merit. In assessing the merits of a candidate, the Selection Committee have due regard to his service record, ability, character and seniority. The list shall contain the name of officers twice the number of vacancies required to be filled by promotion of the members of the Nyayik Sewa.
(4) The Selection Committee shall forward the list of the candidates chosen at the preliminary selection to the Chief Justice along with the names of the officers who, if any, in the opinion of the Committee have been passed over for promotion to the service.
(5) The Court shall examine the recommendations of the Selection Committee and make a final selection for promotion and prepare a list in order of seniority of the candidates who are considered fit for promotion and forward the same to the Governor. The list shall remain operative only till the next recruitment.
The appendix G(1) referred to in Rule 20 above, which prescribes for the subjects for the suitability test as well the methodology of thee suitability test is for convenience is quoted as under:
Appendix G (1)
Rule-20
Syllabus prescribed for the suitability test for promotion from amongst the Civil Judges (Senior Division) under Rule-5(a)
The subjects for the aforementioned test will include: -
The Law of contracts, the Law of Partnership, the Law concerning easements and torts, the Law relating to transfer of property including the principles of equity specifically applicable thereto, the principles of equity with special reference to the law of trust and specific relief, Hindu Law and Mohammedan Law and Constitutional Law.
The Law of evidence, the Criminal Procedure Code and Code of Civil Procedure, including the principles of pleading. The questions set will relate mainly to practical matters such as the framing of charges and issues, the methods of dealing with the evidence of witnesses, the writing of judgment of session trials, appeals, revision and the conduct of cases generally but will not be restricted to them.
Indian Penal Code, the Uttar Pradesh Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act 1951, Uttar Pradesh Urban Buildings (Regulation of Letting, Rent and Eviction) Act, 1972, U.P. Municipalities Act, U.P. Panchayat Raj Act, U.P. Consolidation of Holding Act, U.P. Urban (Planning and Development Act, 1973 together with rules framed under the aforesaid Acts.
(B) (a) The suitability test for adjudging the level of the legal knowledge of the candidate and his awareness of the relevant cases law on the subjects, indicated here-in above, will consist of two parts:-
All candidates will have to appear in a written test carrying a maximum of 100 marks, which will be a test of objective type requiring answering of 50 questions of 2 marks each in one hour duration.
(i) The other part of the suitability test will be for the assessment of the candidate for his continued efficiency, which will be adjudged on the basis of his service record of preceding 10 years from the year of the suitability test. This part of the test will also carry a maximum of 100 marks which will be allotted on the basis of the grading of the officer reflected in the Court’s annual confidential remarks recorded in the character roll providing however for the deduction of the marks for adverse entry as indicate below: -
Grading Marks to be allotted
Outstanding 10
Very good 08
Good 06
Average 04
Poor 00
Adverse entry Minus 2 marks for each year
(C) The marks secured by the candidate in both parts of the suitability test for being eligible for promotion will not be less than 50% in aggregate i.e.100 marks.
The Hon’ble Full Court in its meeting dated 18.5.1985 was pleased to prescribe that:
No officer of the Nyayik Sewa shall be appointed to any post in any capacity in the Higher Judicial Service unless he has held the post of Civil Judge (now Civil Judge [Senior Division]) /Chief Judicial Magistrate at least for three years and his work and conduct has been satisfactory in all respects.
The Hon’ble Court in exercise of its powers under the Uttar Pradesh Higher Judicial Service Rules, 1975 and other enabling provisions in that behalf has determined 170 vacancies in all for recruitment by promotion under Rule 5(a) read with Rule 20 of the Uttar Pradesh Higher Judicial Service Rules,1975.
In view of the provisions in the Uttar Pradesh Higher Judicial Service Rules, 1975 read with resolution aforequoted the following officers fall in the zone of consideration for recruitment by promotion on the basis of Principle of merit-cum-seniority and passing a suitability test:
Sl. No. |
Name of the officer S/Shri/Smt./Miss |
LIST ‘A’- OFFICERS IN SHORT TERM APPOINTMENT AS A STOPGAP ARRANGEMENT UNDER RULES 22(3) OF UPHJS RULES, 1975
|
Pratap Singh-II |
|
Ashok Kumar Awasthi |
|
Jai Prakash Singh-I |
|
Sanjeev Shiromani |
|
Dulare Lal |
|
Ashok Kumar Nigam |
|
Rakesh Kumar Upadhyay |
|
Ram Kailash |
|
Jai Mangal Sharma |
|
Gopal Kulshrestha |
|
Anil Kumar |
|
Ram Krishna Upadhyay |
|
Ashwani Kumar Singh |
|
Chaitanya Kumar Kulshrestha |
|
Shiv Kumar Singh-II |
|
Mahesh Prasad Srivastava |
|
Smt. Kalpana Misra |
|
Smt. Saroj Yadav |
|
Satish Chandra Sharma |
|
Yogendra Singh-II |
|
Smt. Prem Kala Singh |
|
Pradeep Kumar Consul |
|
Nand Lal |
|
Madhu Sudan Wadhwa |
|
Suprendra Pal Goel |
|
Mohd. Zaheer Uddin |
|
Shiva Prasad |
|
Smt. Kamini Pathak |
|
Raj Kumar Tewari |
|
Rajiv Goel |
|
Anil Kumar Pundir |
|
Arvind Kumar Jain |
|
Ram Preeti Dwivedi |
|
Pawan Kumar Chaurasia |
|
Raghvendra Prasad |
|
Naseer Ahmad-II |
|
Vinod Kumar Singh Rathore |
|
Syed Sarwat Mahmood |
|
Devendra Kumar Garg |
|
Rama Kant Misra |
|
Mohd. Aslam |
|
Prem Kumar Singh |
|
Krishna Kant Pandey |
|
Anil Kumar Gupta |
|
Piyush Chandra Srivastava |
|
Deepak Raj |
|
Shashi Mauli Tiwari |
|
Ghan Shyam Pathak |
|
Niraj Kumar Sangal |
|
Anil Kumar Ojha |
|
Upendra Kumar |
|
Hemant Kumar |
|
Girjesh Kumar Pandey |
|
Santosh Kumar Vishwakarma |
|
Jai Krishna Tiwari |
|
Mukesh Prakash |
|
Lokendra Kumar Rathi |
|
Alok Saxena |
|
Rajendra Kumar-III |
|
Hari Singh-III |
|
Amerika Singh |
|
Smt. Sadhna Rani (Thakur) |
|
Chandra Mauli Shukla |
|
Rajendra Chand |
|
Dina Nath Prasad |
|
Brahma Din Verma |
|
Hari Har Prasad Yadav |
|
Damodar Singh |
|
Abdul Qadir |
|
Narendra Deo Misra |
|
Kamal Chaudhary |
|
Subedar Yadav |
|
Nisamuddin |
|
Suresh Singh Yadav |
|
Ashok Kumar Bhardwaj |
|
Ahibaran Singh |
|
Kamla Singh Yadav |
|
Jai Pal Singh-III |
|
Shiv Pal Singh |
|
Sangam Lal |
|
Brajendra Singh-III |
|
Jang Bahadur Singh-III |
|
Biplava Kumar |
|
Vinod Kumar-II |
|
Mahendra Singh-II |
|
Satendra Singh |
|
Pitam Singh |
|
Bikanoo Ram |
|
Ashok Kumar Verma |
|
Chandra Pal |
|
Ram Adhar Ram |
|
Bharat Pandey |
|
Om Prakash Tripathi |
|
Naveen Srivastava |
|
Babu Lal Kesarwani |
|
Ram Krishna Shukla |
|
Umesh Chandra Sharma |
|
Syed Aftab Husain Rizvi |
|
Sohan Lal Srivastava |
|
Shyam Shanker |
|
Dinesh Kumar Sharma-II |
|
Shamsher Chandra |
|
Faridul Haque |
|
Sudhir Kumar-II |
|
Arvind Kumar Singh |
|
Mohammad Husain |
|
Lal Bahadur-II |
|
Surya Kumar Singh |
|
Nag Narain Rai |
|
Vinod Kumar Srivastava-IV |
|
Sanjay |
|
Ajai Tyagi |
|
Vinay Srivastava |
|
Prashant Kumar Charavarty |
|
Sudeep Kumar Banerjee |
|
Syed Waiz Mian |
|
Harish Kumar |
|
Vijay Kumar Agarwal |
|
Ashok Kumar Misra |
|
Akhilesh Kumar Tiwari |
|
Satya Prakash Naik |
|
Pradeep Kumar Dubey |
|
Bani Singh Nirala |
|
Dinesh Kumar Singh-II |
|
Krishna Kumar –IV |
|
Ajai Kumar Srivastava-I |
|
Syed Fariduddin Ashraf |
|
Chandra Bhushan Singh |
|
Tej Bahadur Singh |
|
Ganesh Mohan Sharma |
|
Surendra Pal Singh |
|
Arun Kumar Misra |
|
Santosh Kumar Pandey |
|
Brijesh Kumar Pandey. |
|
Neeraj Nigam |
|
Allah Rakhai |
|
Vidhya Shankar Patel |
|
Govind Ballabh (Sharma) |
|
Yogesh Chandra Tripathi |
|
Mahipat Singh Verma |
|
Krishna Kumar Asthana |
|
Praveen Kumar |
LIST’B’-OFFICERS IN SHORT TERM
APPOINTMENT AS A STOPGAP ARRANGEMENT
UNDER RULES 22(3) OF UPHJS RULES, 1975
TO MAN THE FAST TRACK COURTS
|
Suba Singh |
|
Smt. Jai Shree Ahuja |
|
Pramod Kumar Singh |
|
Pramod Kumar-I |
|
Smt. Renu Agarwal |
|
Mukteshwar Prasad-II |
|
Amar Nath Singh |
|
Prem Mohan Singh |
|
Vishesh Sharma |
|
Mangal Prasad |
|
Ram Nath Dinkar |
|
Udai Singh |
|
Chandra Bhan-III |
|
Ram Adhar |
|
Ram Sahay |
|
Daya Ram Singh-II |
|
Pankaj Gaur |
|
Sarvesh Kumar |
|
Shanti Prakash Arvind |
|
Avnish Kumar Dwivedi |
|
Vijendra Kumar |
|
Charan Singh |
|
Rama Nand |
|
Vinay Kumar |
|
Rama Pati Maurya |
|
Roop Chandra Ram |
|
Ram Prakash-II |
|
Daya Ram-IV |
|
Ganga Ram |
|
Ajay Krishna Vishvesha |
|
Ashok Kumar Singh-III |
|
Dr. Rama Shanker Tripathi |
|
Vinay Kumar Mishra |
|
Shri Kant Verma |
|
Ramesh Gupta |
|
Surendra Kumar Yadav |
|
Kaushalendra Kumar Sinha |
|
Gauri Shanker Gupta |
|
Rajiv Sharma |
|
Lal Chandra-II |
|
Purnendu Kuamr Srivastava |
|
Smt. Neerja Singh |
|
Buddhi Ram |
|
Raghvendra |
|
Arvind Kumar Pandey |
|
Smt. Alka Srivastava |
|
Vidya Prakash Pathak |
|
Mohd. Azahar Husain Idrisi |
|
Ravindra Nath Yadav |
|
Ram Babu Sharma |
|
Ram Manohar Narayan Mishra |
|
Shri Nath Singh |
|
Sushil Kumar-II |
|
Mushir Ahmad Abbasi |
|
Khalil Ahmad |
|
Dinesh Chandra Singh |
|
Om Prakash Mishra-II |
|
Mahtab Ahmad |
|
Ram Chandra-IV |
|
Israr Ahmad |
|
Arun Chandra Srivastava |
|
Surendra Kumar Singh |
|
Rajendra Prasad Gupta |
|
Vinod Kumar Singh-III |
|
Uma Shanker Sharma |
|
Ram Jeet Singh Yadav |
|
Mahmood Ahmad Khan |
|
Harish Kumar Yadav |
|
Peeyush Sharma |
|
Sanjay Kuamr Dey |
|
Devi Shanker Prasad Srivastava |
|
Pramod Kumar Sharma |
|
Aejaz Ahmad Ansari |
|
Neel Kuntha Sahay |
|
Amar Jeet Tripathi |
|
Smt. Poonam Sikand |
|
Mohd. Rais Siddiqui |
|
Rohitash Singh Gangwar |
|
Smt. Jyotsana Sharma |
|
Tanvir Ahmad |
|
Sanjay Khare |
|
Amitabh Sahai |
|
Parmanand Shukla |
|
Shaileshwar Nath Singh |
|
Mahfooz Ali |
|
Rajesh Singh |
|
Nishesh Kumar |
|
Suresh Chandra Rana |
|
Mayank Kumar Jain |
|
Alok Kumar Trivedi |
|
Mohd. Ali |
|
Manvendra Singh |
|
Vinod Kumar-III |
|
Onkar Singh Yadav |
|
Raj Bhan Singh |
|
Suresh Chandra Mishra |
|
Ram Raj |
|
Shiv Shanker Prasad |
|
Mukesh Mishra |
|
Ramesh Chandra-V |
|
Sant Ram |
|
Badam Singh |
|
Vijendra Singh |
|
Satish Kumar-II |
|
Shiv Karan |
|
Abhimanyu |
|
Prem Nath |
|
Gajendra Kumar |
|
Gyan Prakash-II |
|
Anil Kumar Upadhyay |
|
Surendra Singh |
|
Dr. Ashok Kumar Singh-IV |
|
Sarvesh Chandra Pandey |
|
Brij Mohan Gupta-II |
|
Madan Lal Nigam |
|
Surendra Prasad (Mishra) |
|
Dharam Raj Mishra |
|
Anoop Kumar Goel |
|
Manohar Lal |
|
Pradeep Kumar Gupta |
|
Nalin Kuamr Srivastava |
|
Jitendra Kumar |
|
Vivek Kumar Dubey |
|
Yashwant Kumar Mishra |
|
Ram Pal Singh-II |
|
Pramod Kumar Srivastava-II |
|
Abrar Ahmad |
|
Ram Narain Maurya |
|
Rang Narain Pandey |
|
Gyan Prakash Tewari |
|
Jai Prakash Singh-II |
|
Jai Shankar Mishra |
|
Adarsh Kumar Singh Kanaujia |
|
Mridulesh Kumar Singh |
|
Shiv Mani Shukla |
|
Shiv Kumar |
|
Gulab Singh-I |
|
Sanjay Shanker Pandey |
|
Vinay Khare |
|
Kaushalendra Yadav |
|
Narendra Bahadur Yadav |
|
Suresh Chandra-IV |
|
Ashok Kumar-VI |
|
Smt. Mridula Kumar |
|
Mahanth Lal |
|
Kishor Kumar-II |
|
Shashi Kant Upadhyay |
|
Mahendra Kumar Arya |
|
Sanjiv Kumar |
|
Karan Singh Yuvraj |
|
Bijendra Kumar Shailat |
|
Lal Mani |
|
Dr. Rajiv Vikram Singh Gautam |
|
Sgt. Ram Murti Yadav |
|
Sudhir Kumar-III |
|
Chandra Pal Singh |
|
Indra Bhushan Goel |
|
Sushil Kumar Rastogi |
|
Deepak Swaroop Saxena |
|
Ashok Kumar Yadav-I |
|
Ram Baran Saroj |
|
Smt. Sangeeta Srivastava |
|
Girish Kumar Vaish |
|
Avinash Chandra Tripathi |
|
Chandrika Prasad Srivastava |
|
Brijendra Mani Tripathi |
|
Smt. Deepa jain |
|
Rakesh Kumar-III |
|
Satya Ram Yadav |
|
Om Prakash |
|
Vikash Saxena-I |
|
Rakesh Kumar-IV |
|
Shakeel Ahmad Khan |
|
Jyoti Kumar Tripathi |
|
Umesh Chandra |
|
Veer Nayak Singh |
|
Santosh Kumar Srivastava |
|
Jitendra Kumar Pandey |
|
Vikash Saxena-II |
|
Ajai Kumar Srivastava-II |
|
Navneet Kumar |
|
Mohd. Mateen Khan |
|
Umesh Kumar Singh |
|
Aftab Alam Khan |
|
Sita Ram Verma |
|
Mohd. Riyaz |
|
Lal Chandra Gupta |
|
Ram Karan |
|
Ram Sagar |
|
Km. Kumudni verma |
|
Kali Charan-II |
|
Harkesh Kumar |
|
Shobhi Lal |
|
Lalta Prasad-II |
|
Munshi Lal Azad |
|
Gajendra Singh-II |
|
Shree Bhagwan Singh |
|
Avinash Saksena |
|
Jitendra Kumar Singh |
|
Irfan Qamar |
|
Smt. Vani Ranjan Agarwal |
|
Surendra Singh |
|
Piyush Verma |
|
Lallu Singh |
|
Shyam Jeet Yadav |
|
Jai Prakash Singh-III |
|
Ram Milan Singh |
|
Rama Kant Seth |
|
Ashok Kumar-VII |
|
Ravindra Kumar-I |
|
Harish Tripathi |
|
Pankaj Kumar Upadhyay |
|
Satya Prakash Tripathi |
|
Alok Kumar Parasar |
|
Ravindra Vikram Singh |
|
Indra Kumar Pandey |
|
Amit Pal Singh |
|
Praveen Kumar Jain |
|
Narendra Kumar |
|
Raj Singh Verma |
|
Ayaz Ahmad |
|
Praveen Kumar Singh |
|
Brijesh Kumar Mishra |
|
Shyam Narayan Tripathi |
|
Hari Nath Pandey |
|
Shiv Dan Yadav |
|
Mahendra Prasad Chaudhary |
|
Abdul Mobeen |
|
Ramesh Singh |
|
Smt. Anita Raj |
|
Shanker Lal |
|
Vinod Kumar-IV |
|
Ashokeshwar Kumar Ravi |
|
Bhairav Lal |
|
Ram Kripal |
|
Ram Kumar-II |
|
Ram Chandra-V |
|
Dr. (Smt.) Vidushi Singh |
|
Ashok Kumar Premi |
|
Markandey Rai |
|
Nalin Kant Tyagi |
|
Shamsher Khan |
LIST ‘B’-OFFICERS HOLDING POSTS IN THE
CIVIL JUDGE (SENIOR DIVISION) CADRE
|
Syed Hasan (Provisionally) |
|
Shree Narain Upadhyay(Provisionally) |
|
Satish Kumar Kain |
|
Suresh Chandra Savita |
|
Chandra Shekhar Prasad |
|
Virendra Chaubey |
|
Bans Raj |
|
Rajendra Ram |
|
Prakash Chandra Dwivedi |
|
Arvind Kumar-I |
|
Brij Bhushan Yadav |
|
Sita Ram Nigam |
|
Dharmendra Pratap Narain Singh |
|
Sardar Singh Chauhan |
|
Ram Naresh Maurya |
|
Brij Lal |
|
Jagdish-II |
|
Adil Aftab Ahmad |
|
Krishna Pal Singh |
|
Akhilesh Dubey |
|
Ramesh Chand |
|
Sanjay Kumar-I |
|
Smt. Reeta Kaushik |
|
Mohan Lal Vishwakarma |
|
Diwakar Prasad Chaturvedi |
|
Syed Sarwar Husain Rizvi |
|
Paras Nath Rai |
|
Prakash Nath Srivastava |
|
Bhu Deo Gautam |
|
Manoj Kumar Shukla |
|
Ram Nagina Yadav |
|
Atul Srivastava |
|
Sunil Kumar Mishra |
|
Kamlesh Dubey |
|
Ram Kishor Shukla |
|
Anand Prakash-I |
|
Shiva Kumar Singh |
|
Dr. Bal Mukund |
|
Mohd. Ibrahim |
|
Birendra Kumar Singh |
|
Ashok Kumar Singh-V |
|
Smt. Alpana |
|
Mukesh Kumar Singhal |
|
Amar Pal Singh |
|
Shesh Mani |
|
Shamshul Haque |
|
Rajendra Prasad Srivastava-III |
|
Gyanesh Kumar |
|
Smt. Beena Chaudhary |
|
Narendra Singh |
|
Bhagwati Prasad Saxena |
|
Arun Kumar Pathak |
|
Amar Jeet Verma |
|
Shashi Bhushan Pandey |
|
Randheer Singh |
|
Indra Deo Dubey |
|
Sunil Kumar Singh-I |
|
Jamal Masood Abbasi |
|
Kripa Shankar Sharma |
|
Sanjay Kumar-II |
|
Brijendra Kumar Tyagi |
|
Sham Kumar |
|
Shailesh Kumar Tiwari |
|
Surendra Prasad Yadav |
|
Avinash Narayan Pandey |
|
Mohd. Shareef |
|
Himanshu Bhatnagar |
|
Surendra Nath Tripathi |
|
Mittar Pal Singh |
|
Ram Kushal |
|
Ram Pyare |
|
Satya Prakash |
|
Pradeep Singh |
|
Angad Prasad-I |
|
Smt. Kumud Pal |
|
Krishna Kumar Singh |
|
Mahendra Pratap Singh Yadav |
|
Raj Narain Singh |
|
Smt. Anupama Gopal Nigam |
|
Hamid-Ullah |
|
Ram Murti Yadav |
|
Satya Vir Singh Yadav |
|
Pramod Kumar-II |
|
Ram Kesh Singh |
|
Shiv Singh Yadav |
|
Dev Raj Prasad Singh |
|
Ashwani Kumar Dubey |
|
Mahendra Pal Singh |
|
Raj Kumar Bansal |
|
Dhruva Kumar Tiwari |
|
Raj Bahadur Singh Maurya |
|
Jagdish Kumar |
|
Babu Prasad |
|
Lal Chandra-III |
|
Virendra Kumar |
|
Smt. Brijesh Singh |
|
Smt. Renu Rao |
|
Ram Suchit |
|
Mahesh Nautiyal |
|
Aniruddha Maurya |
|
Rajesh Kumar-I |
|
Prabhakar `Rao' |
|
Ram Raj Ram |
|
Suresh Chandra Bharti |
|
Suresh Chandra Arya |
|
Bachchu Singh |
|
Anil Kumar |
|
Suresh Chand |
|
Jagdish Prasad-IV |
|
Shambhu Nath |
|
Rahul Kumar Katyan |
|
Anupati Ram Yadav |
|
Tahshildar Singh |
The suitability test as per syllabus and modality prescribed in appendix G (1) referred to in Rule 5(a) read with Rule 20 of the Uttar Pradesh Higher Judicial Service Rules, 1975, as amended up to date, is scheduled to be held on 10th February 2008. The time and place of the suitability test shall be communicated afterwards.